Dear all,
I am running an IV fixed effects estimation (xtivreg2) using a panel of around 3000 observations, for three years.
My dependent variable is a binary variable (at the individual level), while my independent variable is an aggregate variable (regional level) where I have only 20 regions. I use IV, with more instruments than endogenous variables (which are between 2 and 4 depending on the specification). The Sargan test is ok.
My problem is that when I am running xtivreg2, clustering for the region, instruments turn out to be very weak, thing that does not happen using robust or clustering at the individual level. I checked the first stage outputs and it appears that the t_statistics for only one endogenous regression is very low, and therefore also its F of the first stage.
Could this be related to the fact that I have a short panel and only 20 region clusters? Consider that the clusters are fixed within individuals and therefore regional fixed effects are dropped from the Fixed Effects estimation. What can I do to solve this problem? Can I only cluster at the individual level?
Thanks for any advice,
Ale
I am running an IV fixed effects estimation (xtivreg2) using a panel of around 3000 observations, for three years.
My dependent variable is a binary variable (at the individual level), while my independent variable is an aggregate variable (regional level) where I have only 20 regions. I use IV, with more instruments than endogenous variables (which are between 2 and 4 depending on the specification). The Sargan test is ok.
My problem is that when I am running xtivreg2, clustering for the region, instruments turn out to be very weak, thing that does not happen using robust or clustering at the individual level. I checked the first stage outputs and it appears that the t_statistics for only one endogenous regression is very low, and therefore also its F of the first stage.
Could this be related to the fact that I have a short panel and only 20 region clusters? Consider that the clusters are fixed within individuals and therefore regional fixed effects are dropped from the Fixed Effects estimation. What can I do to solve this problem? Can I only cluster at the individual level?
Thanks for any advice,
Ale